Philadelphia 1911 (5)




Results
 
Crosstable scores
Name   Edo    Dev.   Score  /  Games   
Edwards, Edward    2229 (74) 6 / 8 
Smith, Le Roy    2071 (106) 5 / 8 
Ash, Isaac    2069 (111) 5 / 8 
Lipman, L.R.    1927 (118) 3 / 8 
MacInnes, J.    1723 (144) 1 / 8 
 
 
Match scores
Name   Edo    Dev.   Score  /  Games 
Edwards, Edward    2229 (74) 0.5 / 1 
Smith, Le Roy    2071 (106) 0.5 / 1 
 
Ash, Isaac    2069 (111) 0.5 / 1 
Lipman, L.R.    1927 (118) 0.5 / 1 
 

Event table notes

Event data
Name: Rex Club Championship
Place: Philadelphia
Start date: 1911
End date: May 1911
 
Notes:
The scores given by Hilbert do not add up to the correct total for a double-round all-play-all. Probably the half points were draws which were not counted and replayed. I am giving the whole number scores for the crosstable, which do add up to the correct total, and recording separately (as match results to fit my formatting) two extra draws Edwards-Smith and Ash-Lipman, though these might have been betwen the opposite pairings. Hilbert does not specify exact dates, but the report of the results was given at a dinner on 21 May 1911, so I am guessing that the tournament finished that month.
 
References
Books
   Hilbert, Writings in Chess History, page 313
Tournament page created: 14 Sept. 2015