Edinburgh 1874




Results
 
Crosstable scores
Name   Edo    Dev.   Score  /  Games   
Fraser, James    2191 (71) 13.5 / 15 
Robertson, James    1989 (71) 9 / 15 
Macfie, John    1951 (69) 8 / 15 
 
 

Event table notes

Event data
Name: Edinburgh Club Tournament
Place: Edinburgh
Start date: June 1874
End date: June 1874
 
Notes:
The Field gives scores for only the top three prize-winners, but also lists Meikle, Dr. Smith and Duke, saying the won 'the other three prizes'. The Edinburgh Evening News of 30 Jun. 1874 (p.2) lists only four prize-winners, Dr James Frazer, Colonel J.A. Robertson, John Macfie, and C. Meikle. The three scores given are out of 15, and I am guessing that this was a 6-player triple-round all-play-all tournament. The 1873 event was a triple-round all-play-all, and if the 1874 tournament was a single-round all-play-all with 16 players, the average of the remaining 13 players would be 6.88, which seems unlikely. If a 6-player triple-round all-play-all, the average score of the remaining 3 would be 4.83, which seems much more likely.
 
References
Periodicals
   [EEN], no. 343, 30 June 1874, page 2
   [Fld], 18 July 1874

Tournament page created: 25 Dec. 2021