| Ratings 
 
 
  | Year | Rank | Edo | Dev. | Games |  
  | 1871 | 330 | 2008 | (90) | 14 |  
  | 1872 | 356 | 1998 | (94) | 0 |  
  | 1873 | 372 | 1988 | (98) | 0 |  
  | 1874 | 405 | 1978 | (101) | 0 |  
  | 1875 | 436 | 1968 | (103) | 0 |  
  | 1876 | 436 | 1958 | (105) | 0 |  
  | 1877 | 429 | 1948 | (105) | 0 |  
  | 1878 | 444 | 1938 | (106) | 0 |  
  | 1879 | 444 | 1928 | (105) | 0 |  
  | 1880 | 476 | 1918 | (104) | 0 |  
  | 1881 | 558 | 1908 | (103) | 0 |  
  | 1882 | 601 | 1898 | (100) | 0 |  
  | 1883 | 666 | 1888 | (97) | 0 |  
  | 1884 | 751 | 1878 | (93) | 4 |  
  | 1885 | 715 | 1878 | (94) | 0 |  
  | 1886 | 718 | 1878 | (95) | 0 |  
  | 1887 | 698 | 1878 | (94) | 0 |  
  | 1888 | 708 | 1878 | (93) | 0 |  
  | 1889 | 690 | 1879 | (91) | 0 |  
  | 1890 | 725 | 1879 | (87) | 0 |  
  | 1891 | 725 | 1879 | (82) | 0 |  
  | 1892 | 771 | 1879 | (76) | 11 |  
  | 1893 | 800 | 1883 | (79) | 0 |  
  | 1894 | 818 | 1887 | (79) | 0 |  
  | 1895 | 817 | 1891 | (78) | 0 |  
  | 1896 | 814 | 1894 | (75) | 5 |  
  | 1897 | 830 | 1889 | (73) | 8 |  
  | 1898 | 842 | 1882 | (79) | 0 |  
  | 1899 | 882 | 1874 | (83) | 6 |  
 
Rating table notes
 | 
| Biographical data |  | 
   | Name: Punchard, Charles |  
   | Born: 14 Mar. 1833 |  
   | Died: 8 Jan. 1905 |  |  |  
   | Notes: |  
   | Full name from correspondence from David Cohen. Yanofsky has 'M. Princhard'? Wright has 'Punchard, J.' at Toronto 1892, but 'Punchard, Charles' at Orillia 1897. I guess that these are actually the same and that the initial 'J.' was an error. |  |  |  |  
   | References |  | 
| Books |  
   | Hilbert, Writings in Chess History, page 39, 184 |  | Periodicals |  
   | [TG], vol. 28, 18 Aug. 1871, page 3 |  
   | [TG], vol. 53, no. 14777, 30 June 1897, page 10 |  
   | [TG], vol. 53, no. 14778, 1 July 1897, page 8 |  
   | [TG], 9 Jan. 1905, page 5 |  | Web |  
   | Wright, Stephen.  [Early Canadian Championships] |  
   | [Charles Leslie Punchard (1833 - 1905)] |  |  |